Blog Entry

Coach Killers, Week 16: Is Sanchez the answer?

Posted on: December 27, 2011 11:45 am
Coach Killers is your weekly look around the league at those performances, decisions and "Wait, what did he just do?!" moments that put the guy in charge squarely on the ol' hot seat.

By Ryan Wilson

Mark Sanchez - Jets

Is Sanchez in NY's future? Rex says yes. (AP Photo)
With each passing game, Sanchez confirms what everybody already suspected (even if Rex Ryan won't admit it publicly): he's an average NFL quarterback. There are worse fates (he could be Tyler Palko or Caleb Hanie), but Sanchez's success is contingent on the formula the Jets had working during the 2009 and 2010 seasons: ground, pound and a stifling defense.

In 2011, the rushing attack and the vaunted defense has been inconsistent, New York has fallen behind, and Sanchez hasn't been able to get the Jets in the end zone late in games. The result: eight wins against seven losses -- the latest coming Saturday against the Giants -- and the very real possibility of missing the playoffs for the first time in Rex Ryan's tenure as head coach.

“They were definitely the better team this year,” Ryan said after the 29-14 loss to the Giants. “Clearly, I was wrong. I will take the responsibility. It is on my shoulders and it should be. That’s just the way it is.”

That's what Ryan has to say -- the buck stops with him, after all -- but he's not calling offensive plays. That falls to Brian Schottenheimer, who dialed up 59 (fifty-nine!) pass plays. Sanchez completed just 30 attempts (51 percent), threw one touchdown vs. two interceptions and was sacked five times. By the end of the day, he looked out of sorts and out of confidence.

It's so bad that we're again hearing murmurs that Sanchez may not be the longterm answer at quarterback for the Jets, sentiments that come up a half-dozen times each season.'s Mike Freeman writes Monday that Schottenheimer's job is probably less secure than Sanchez's at this point.

"The inevitable Sanchez microscopic exam started immediately after that Giants loss. The site reported the Jets were having doubts about Sanchez. The New York Post loosely reported that offensive coordinator Brian Schottenheimer might be coaching for his job this week. The latter, I’m told by someone I trust, is more likely the truth."

Wherever reality lies -- and Rex has both Mark and Brian's back-- the point remains: Sanchez has yet to prove that he's a capable NFL quarterback. He thrives as a complimentary piece within a system but he's not the guy you want trying to bring the team back from a late-game deficit. Maybe he'll evolve into that player someday, but through nearly three NFL seasons, he's more game manager than game winner.

Tim Tebow - Broncos

After seven wins in his first eight games as Denver's starting quarterback, Tebow has now dropped two in a row and the Broncos are 8-7. A Week 17 win gives them the division crown and a home playoff game, but that will likely be against the Steelers or Ravens.

For now, though, the big issue is if defenses have figured out how to stop Denver's option attack and whether the offense has an answer to it.

The Bills, with nothing to play for after having lost seven in a row, intercepted Tebow four times (returning two for touchdowns). And while Tebow's numbers are troubling (13 of 30 for 185 yards, 1 TD, 4 INTs and 3 sacks) he wasn't the same guy who was manhandled by the Lions back in Week 8. That Tebow looked confused all afternoon; this Tebow struggled with the Bills' scheme but wasn't overwhelmed to the point of paralysis. That scheme, by the way, wasn't some complicated Dick LeBeau zone blitz concoction. It was a stout four-man rush with seven men in coverage (including a quarterback spy). Tebow wasn't allowed to run for large chunks but was forced to stay in the pocket and win the game with his arm. Obviously, he couldn't do it.

Now the Broncos have a week to work out the kinks and hope everything's clicking should they make it into the postseason. Because if they don't … well, God help us because we're going to spend the spring and summer wondering who will be Denver's starting quarterback in 2012. And, really, nobody wants that.

Phillip Taylor - Browns

Taylor's gaffe was costly. (Getty Images)
Saturday's loss isn't entirely Phil Taylor's fault. The 2011 first-round pick wasn't solely responsible for the Ravens jumping out to a 17-0 lead. But it was his offsides penalty late in the fourth quarter with Cleveland trailing 20-14 that guaranteed the Browns would lose their fifth straight and remain winless in the AFC North this season.

After stuffing running back Ray Rice on third down, Baltimore faced a fourth-and-2 at the Browns' 37-yard line with just under two minutes to go in the game. The Ravens' options: attempting a 55-yard field goal, going for it on fourth down or punting. After a timeout, Baltimore's offense took the field, presumably to draw the Browns offside and keep the drive alive. Cleveland's defensive coaches warned players of as much … moments before Joe Flacco hard-counted and  coaxed Taylor into jumping early. First down Ravens, game over.

"It was the first hard count and we stayed onside. The second time, I just jumped," Taylor told The Associated Press. "Of course you feel bad but you just got to move on."

For the Browns, that means moving on to Week 17 where they will face the Steelers in a game Pittsburgh would like to win, even if it means doing so without starter Ben Roethlisberger, who was injured the first time these teams met in Week 14. (If the Ravens lose to the Bengals and Pittsburgh prevails in Cleveland, the Steelers would win the AFC North and get a first-round bye.)

Flacco, who has taken his share of criticism this season, was shocked Taylor fell for the hard count (it's the NFL equivalent of falling for the "pitcher fakes to third before throwing to first" routine in baseball).

“I don’t know if I’ve ever been in position for that to happen," Flacco said. "It’s never worked.”

There's a first time for everything, especially when you're facing the Browns.

Early Doucet - Cardinals

Poor Early Doucet. He was attacked by the seldom seen Paul Brown Stadium turf monster at the worst possible moment, and instead of hauling in possibly the easiest touchdown pass of his career, he was instead picking himself off the field as the ball skipped out of the end zone incomplete.

The specifics: facing 4th and 5 from the Bengals 17-yard line with 1:16 to go and trailing 23-16, Cardinals quarterback John Skelton threw to what appeared to be a wide open Doucet. Except he tripped and fell, as did Arizona's dwindling playoff hopes.

Turf monster avoids the pass interference call despite tripping Early Doucet.

It gets worse: the father of teammate Larry Fitzgerald called Doucet out, first on Twitter ("Doucet bombed this year he drops to many passes not a dependable No.2. Needs to work harder at his job. He dropped 5 TDs this year.") then to's Mike Sando.

“I just know that Larry invited him to come and work out with him this summer and some guys take initiative and do it, some guys don’t,” Larry Fitzgerald Sr. said. “But with the lockout, I thought he would have worked on it a little harder. That is me. People criticize me because they think I talk too much. That is just how I see it.”

On Monday, the Arizona Republic's Kent Somers wrote that "from previous conversations with Doucet and coaches, the Cardinals were happy with Doucet's off-season work. He was rehabbing from sports hernia surgery, and the Cardinals approved of his program. Receivers coach John McNulty complimented Doucet on reporting to training camp in shape."

Not to worry. Fitzgerald Sr. says he "wasn't picking on" Doucet. “I track when he drops the ball in critical situations. They use Larry the way they are going to use him, so they know others are going to be singled [in coverage]. The Ravens game, he dropped one on the goal line. I remember other games. Now that they’re out of the playoffs, I’m putting it out there.”

Can't wait to hear what Senior thinks about Kevin Kolb and/or John Skelton.

LeGarrette Blount - Buccaneers

Like Phil Taylor, it's unfair to point to Blount and say, "Yep, it's all his fault." But head coach Raheem Morris thought enough of Blount's performance to call him out after Tampa Bay's latest no-show performance, this time against the Panthers. On the Bucs' very first offensive play, Blount muffed the handoff from quarterback Josh Freeman. When an NFL team struggles with something as basic as a handoff it's probably time to hit the reset button. Which is exactly what will happen to Morris shortly after the season ends, and possibly to plenty of names currently on the roster, Blount included.

"To not get that play executed on the first play of the football game is unacceptable,'' Morris said according to the Tampa Tribune. "You're obviously not ready to play. I'm not ready to give up on him (Blount), but you can't let your team down that way.''

Blount was just as frank when asked about the play and the subsequent benching.

"It happens. Whenever you feel like something is not going your way, you've got to look somewhere else. If a back's been giving up the ball the whole season, you've got to find someone else to do the job. It was a miscommunication. We fumbled the ball.''

Meanwhile, veteran cornerback Ronde Barber, wholly unimpressed with the Bucs' defense, says that the same team that won 10 games last season is now full of players looking out for themselves. Such is the destiny for four-win clubs.

"That was an embarrassing performance, really, in the run game," Barber said after Tampa Bay allowed 270 yards rushing. "It's frustrating to watch because you know what the problems are. It looks like guys want to do their own thing. You've got to believe the guy next to you is going to do his job. … They didn't even need [Steve Smith] today. That just shows how far they've come and how far we've gotten away from what we used to be.''

(To be fair, the Panthers did have Cam, who has come so far, so fast, he's already ascended to one-word-name status). Which is why when we see the Bucs in 2012 they'll look nothing like the team that limped to the finish in 2011.

For more NFL news, rumors and analysis, follow @EyeOnNFL on Twitter, Like Us on Facebook, subscribe to our NFL newsletter, and while you're at it, add our RSS Feed.

Since: Aug 17, 2006
Posted on: December 28, 2011 12:01 pm

Coach Killers, Week 16: Is Sanchez the answer?

Tebow in Denver.
I would be shocked, no matter what happens the rest of this year, if one of the big QB's drops to the Broncos in the draft Elway doesn't take him.  I am not saying Tebow can't win.  Not saying he should lose the job after losing 2 games.  All I am saying is a HOF QB runs your team.  Elway won with a strong arm and some athleticism.  I don't see him converting to some option offensive mindset overnight thinking that will get his team over the hump.  The guy played the position for 20 years so I doubt 1/2 season has him convinced that the offense they run now is the new way to win in the NFL.
just my .02 on the whole thing.

Since: Aug 24, 2006
Posted on: December 28, 2011 9:01 am

Coach Killers, Week 16: Is Sanchez the answer?

IF the Colts win the Andrew Luck bowl, Peyton Manning would become available.Then the Jets could draft a qb & he'd have a couple years of learning from Manning.

Since: Aug 24, 2006
Posted on: December 28, 2011 8:53 am

Coach Killers, Week 16: Is Sanchez the answer?

Since you asked........I didn't fall into the Tebow trap like half the country.I've already voiced my opinion on that & was called a hater.That's what people say these days when there is a disagreement.I don't think there's anything that can be done that would make TT an NFL QB.Right now he's just pretending to be one & teams will make adjustments that will make him look even worse.I guess they could make him a running back, but I don't see him excelling at that either.
There is one thing I've learned from this saga:The Denver Broncos AND their fans have a lot to learn about the NFL.My ten year old knew Tebow wasn't NFL material.The Tebow train was nearly full & if TT were to win another couple games, that train would fill up again.Apparently giving up on Tebow in Denver is akin to giving up smoking. 

Since: Jan 2, 2008
Posted on: December 27, 2011 4:18 pm

Coach Killers, Week 16: Is Sanchez the answer?

Uh , Sanchez threw for 413 yrds and 4 TD's in the 2009 Rose Bowl against Penn State.. He only started that year his Junior year then left for the Jets..I blame the Jets  for him not improving. just goes to show you the lack of talent in QB spots these days when u have to entice underclassmen to come out early and throw them into line of fire. Whenever a star QB goes down Bret Favre's name comes up, or Kerry Collins, Garrard etc

Since: Aug 2, 2007
Posted on: December 27, 2011 2:28 pm

Coach Killers, Week 16: Is Sanchez the answer?

I said it B4 and will say it again, The Jets NEED to move on past the Sanchez Era or it will end even worse, He is not getting better AT ALL!! Point Blank, He wil never bring us to a Super Bowl Let alone win 1, I say you draft a QB in this years draft maybe a 2ND Rd Pick.
It does not have to be a 1ST Round pick, Look what the Jags got on Blaine Gabbert, Need I say more , The guy is Terrible!!
I would love to see Sanchez gone, I am starting to like him less and less each game , He is Just not a Winner and never wil be.
I look at QBS like D Brees, Aaron Rodgers, and Even Brady as much as it kills me to say LOL! and Sanchez wil never be half as good as them. Im sorry its just my opinion.,

Since: Sep 11, 2006
Posted on: December 27, 2011 1:14 pm

Coach Killers, Week 16: Is Sanchez the answer?

People criticize me because they think I talk too much.
People criticize you because you do talk too much. In fact, as far as I can tell Lawrence, talking is the only thing you do that is noteworthy. Unfortunately, it is not noteworthy in a good way.

Since: Dec 27, 2011
Posted on: December 27, 2011 12:37 pm
This comment has been removed.

Post Deleted by Administrator

Since: Jan 19, 2007
Posted on: December 27, 2011 12:30 pm

Coach Killers, Week 16: Is Sanchez the answer?

Does anyone think Tebow will become the pocket passer he needs to be as an NFL QB? Now that his running game has been shut down,  now that his "believe in yourself" kitsch has failed badly for two straight weeks, what is left for Tim Tebow? Elway must be pi$$ed, because he had not bought into Tebow all season, knew it in his gut, and when he finally goes "all in" under the Tebow spell, it all falls apart. The Broncos have no business being in the playoffs, and will be slaughtered by the Steelers in 2 weeks if they make it in.

The views expressed in this blog are solely those of the author and do not reflect the views of CBS Sports or