Blog Entry

Film Room: Giants vs. Cowboys preview

Posted on: December 29, 2011 11:06 am

Posted by Eye on Football Analyst Andy Benoit

An NFC East championship game in primetime – no further introduction needed. Here’s the breakdown.

1. Reviewing Week 14
These teams gave us a classic Sunday night showdown just a few weeks ago. That contest was defined by mistakes more than anything. Tony Romo posted good numbers but missed a few throws that would have changed the outcome. His only completion to Dez Bryant was a 50-yard touchdown against a blown coverage.

The Cowboys defense blew several coverages of its own, leading to a 400-yard night for Eli Manning and prompting Rob Ryan later to scale back the complexity of his scheme in 2:00 type situations. Big-time throws against poor pass defense was why a game that was 34-22 Cowboys with under 6:00 to play wound up being 37-34 Giants.

2. The star quarterbacks in big games
The common perception is that Eli Manning is a big game riser and Tony Romo is a big game faller. The Week 14 battle only reaffirmed this; Manning was absolutely magnificent on the final two touchdown drives, fitting balls into tight windows and, as he’d been doing all night, quickly diagnosing and dissecting the Cowboys’ Byzantine blitzes. Romo, on the other hand, missed a third-and-five throw to Miles Austin with 2:25 remaining that would have sealed the win.

That throw came against an all-out, Cover 0 blitz. In the past, Romo’s inability to recognize blitzes before and after the snap often led to his blunders. Those issues, however, have been largely corrected this season. And yet, because of what happened against the Jets in Week 1, and because of the interception-riddled second half meltdown against the Lions in Week 4, Romo’s reputation remains that of a choker.

That’s mostly an unfair and overly simplistic characterization of a quality veteran. If not for the botched field goal hold at Seattle in the ’06 wild card loss – a play that had nothing to do with quarterbacking skills – Romo almost certainly wouldn’t be thought of as a late-game anything.
That said, Romo has indeed made some mistakes in critical moments. Most of those have been due to defenses confounding him with false looks. The broadcast viewers might tie this to Romo feeling stressed in crunch time; the film viewers tie it back to Romo’s mediocrity at reading defenses before the snap. When you’re a sandlot player, you’re reactionary. A reactionary player is much easier to trick – especially late in games after he’s gotten comfortable reacting to certain looks the same way.

This same concept applies in the other direction with Manning. He’s a splendid field general, audibling at the line of scrimmage, running the no-huddle offense and trusting his eyes and underrated arm strength in the face of pressure. While reactive quarterbacking is prone to defensive manipulation late in games, proactive quarterbacking is apt for defensive manipulation. You change your defensive looks and play aggressively to bait a reactionary quarterback into a mistake. Against a proactive quarterback, you change your looks and play aggressively so that he doesn’t bait you into a mistake.

The relevance of this sexy “big moment quarterbacking” storyline is debatable. As stated before, Romo has improved his mental approach to the game. And just because Manning has been great in crunch time doesn’t mean he’s unstoppable (especially given how up-and-down his receivers have been).

Dez needs to work on his disappearing act. (Getty Images)

3. Pass games
It’s been far too easy for defenses to take away Dez Bryant this season. The Giants had no trouble doing this with Corey Webster a few weeks ago. They also took away Jason Witten by smacking him with a defensive end or linebacker as he came off the line. Don’t be surprised if the Cowboys split Witten to the slot to prevent this from happening again.

Also, don’t be surprised if the Cowboys line up in three receiver sets to force the Giants into their nickel D. That nickel D has been poor in coverage the past few weeks, mainly because of Prince Amukamara. The first-round rookie has since been benched, with safety Antrel Rolle moving back to slot corner. The Cowboys should eagerly test Rolle with either Miles Austin or Laurent Robinson, both excellent route runners.

4. Run games
The Cowboys lost DeMarco Murray for the season in their last meeting with the Giants. Felix Jones showed his uncanny burst and acceleration in the lone game of consequence since then (Week 15 at Tampa Bay), but that was against the worst run defense in football.

It remains to be seen whether the Cowboys can sustain on the ground against a quality opponent. Expect them to try to establish the run, especially if the Giants play their three-safety nickel defense against base offensive personnel (something they did a bit against the Jets). Jones’ might also run out of three-receiver sets against that nickel D, as that’s a good way to take advantage of his proficiency on draws.

New York’s run game remains unimpressive, though there were a few signs of life last week. Brandon Jacobs and Ahmad Bradshaw both ran with power after averaging barely one yard per carry after contact against the Redskins in Week 15. David Baas is back at center after missing several weeks with migraines. Baas has been below average overall this season but at least offers a tad more short-area mobility than backup Kevin Boothe.

5. Up tempo?
The Meadowlands crowd will be in full throat – especially early. The Cowboys may want to go no-huddle to quell the crowd and dictate the flow.

A quick tempo can also be a good way to calm a pass-rush, which is critical when facing Justin Tuck, Jason Pierre-Paul and, perhaps, Osi Umenyiora. And the less time the Giants defense has between snaps, the harder it will be for them to change their coverages, which coordinator Perry Fewell likes to do.

So who will win? Check our NFL expert picks for all Week 17 games

Follow @Andy_Benoit on Twitter or contact him at

Since: Dec 30, 2011
Posted on: December 30, 2011 10:18 pm

Film Room: Giants vs. Cowboys preview

OMG, why can't someone be a Dallas Cowboy's fan on this page?  All the commentators are nay-saying...then every single other comment is bashing my BOYS....I say this...Dallas will come away w/a win and will show those GIANTS that the COWBOYS do know how to kick their rears and just how hard they CAN do it!!!  So, how bout it anyone else who KNOWS we are capable as a team...w/out any mistakes...we CAN win this game!!  Romo, praying that your hand is well, not bothering you and that you will come out and PLAY BALL!!!  LOVE my Dallas Cowboys~~~America's Team, of course~

beer is great
Since: Mar 18, 2011
Posted on: December 30, 2011 8:39 pm
This comment has been removed.

Post Deleted by Administrator

Since: Jan 19, 2009
Posted on: December 30, 2011 8:33 pm

Film Room: Giants vs. Cowboys preview

Romo Beat the Eagles 2 years ago to win the division, and beat them a week later in the playoffs. He is not a choke artist as all say he is.

Since: May 27, 2009
Posted on: December 30, 2011 7:28 pm

Film Room: Giants vs. Cowboys preview

Unfortunately, no one cares about the Bengels, even in Cincinnati. A bad Giants-Cowboys game is better than any game the Bengals have played in in 20 years.

Since: Jan 8, 2008
Posted on: December 30, 2011 5:35 pm

Film Room: Giants vs. Cowboys preview

Two crappy teams fighting to win the division, either deserves the home field in the first round.

Since: Jun 27, 2011
Posted on: December 30, 2011 3:35 pm

Film Room: Giants vs. Cowboys preview

Giants D may fair better being Romo will have a tough time throwing with his bad paw. look for the G men to inally break out with a 1-2 attack from Bradshaw-jacobs and ware late in the game to ice it. Giants 27 The Boys' 17

Since: Oct 2, 2006
Posted on: December 30, 2011 12:22 pm

Film Room: Giants vs. Cowboys preview

G-men cannot stop anyone on D.  Unless you're counting on Romo severely overthrowing a sure touchdown again, don't expect Big Blue to come through.

Since: Dec 3, 2007
Posted on: December 29, 2011 10:27 pm

Film Room: Giants vs. Cowboys preview

Last week it was Jets-Giants all week, blah, blah, blah.  A battle between two .500 teams.
This week the big game is Giants-Cowboys, a battle between two .500 teams and a contest to see who gets eliminated in the first round of the playoffs?

How about featuring a game that means something.  The Ravens could end up being anything from the # 1 seed in the AFC or the # 5 seed.  The Bengals could make the playoffs sending three teams from the strongest division in football.  That's something to talk about!

Since: Mar 2, 2009
Posted on: December 29, 2011 6:26 pm

Film Room: Giants vs. Cowboys preview

Giants, just remind the cowboys it is january. That will do them in.

The views expressed in this blog are solely those of the author and do not reflect the views of CBS Sports or