There are people in this country, in the world, who simply do not have the intelligence to make a lot of money. It's not about education or work ethic, it's about them not being smart enough to get a great paying job. Even more so, we simply can't all be rich. there are going to be poor people, there are going to be low paying jobs. You right wingers always want to talk about punishing the rich for thier success but you're OK with punishing the poor for their lack of success no matter why they are not successful. If it were possible that we could ALL be successful then I would agree but we can't be. Someone has to cook at McDonald's, someone has to run the McDonald's, someone has to do accounting work at McDonald's Corp offices and someone has to be the CEO of McDonald's. Someone has to work at Walmart, someone has to run the Walmart, someone has to do accounting for Walmart and someone has to be the CEO of Walmart. Someone has to be the officer, someone has to be the sargent, someone has to the the chief and someone has to be the commissioner of the police department. Someone has to clean the school, someone has to teach our children, someone has to be the principal and someone has to be the superintendant. Someone has to clean the Chevy plant, someone has to work the assembly line, someone has to run the plant and someone has to be Chevy's president. the point being not everyone can be a CEO or an accountant, someone has to break their back and others have to supervise them. someone has to have the chitt job and not everyone can be the CEO. So the people who were lucky enough to be able to put themselves in a position where they can make a lot of money pay more into the system and the people who were not lucky enough to put themselves in that position pay less of their money into the system. I'm not going to feel bad for a person making a million dollars a year having to give $400,000 of it to the federal government when the vast majority of us won't make even that $400,000 in 4 years. Not only can you survive on that $600,000, you can live very well on it. You can feel sorry for them if you want to. I would personally have no problem giving up that $400,000 if I would be bringing home $600,000. I wouldn't think of it as being punished but I would think of paying 15% of my income on $35,000 as being punished if someone making $3.5 million is also paying 15%.