Replay for penalties???

Views:      
 
 
-

Replay for penalties???

February 3, 2013 11:06 pm

What do you think?
 
tol
SinceFeb 3, 2013
-

Replay for penalties???

February 3, 2013 11:12 pm

THAT MAY HAPPEN AFTER THIS AND ALSO SEATTLE/PITTSBURGH.

randyman5
SinceSep 13, 2006
-

Replay for penalties???

February 3, 2013 11:19 pm

Something needs to change. 
tol
SinceFeb 3, 2013
-

Replay for penalties???

February 3, 2013 11:20 pm

Absolutely not.  You'd be out of challenges after 8 minutes in the first quarter.

The truth is there are bad calls all the time.  Dont' let that be an excuse for you to lose.  Overcome them. 

P.S. that ball wasn't going to be caught either way.

kylews8973
SinceJun 7, 2012
-

Replay for penalties???

February 4, 2013 1:19 am

P.S. that ball wasn't going to be caught either way.
And Crabtree committed just as much as a foul as the defender.  He had his forearm in the face pushing the defender down.  I just find it hilarious what people choose and choose not to see.  I see people crying about the 2 point attempt saying the Ravens were offsided.  Ed Reed was not offsides.  He timed it perfect, and made a good play.  Truth is that the 49ers benefitted more than anything with the power outage.  The Ravens were absolutely manhandling them, had all the momentum and were controlling the pace of the game the way they wanted to.  Then the lights go out and its 84 minutes until the offense finally gets back on the field from the first half.  If you don't think momentum plays as big a part in the game as all the supposed terrible calls that went against the 9ers than none of you have played football before.  Momentum is everything and the Ravens were getting ready to curb stomp the 9ers. 
ChubRock50
SinceOct 31, 2006
-

Replay for penalties???

February 4, 2013 1:25 am

I think it's quite funny how all the 49ers fans are complaining about the PI at the end or whatever they claim it was.  The power outage is the reason this game was even close.  28-6 and ALL the momentum in the world, looked like a blow out was coming, and all of a sudden there is a power outage, that seemed a bit shady to me.  As soon as the power outage happened I looked at my brother and said "Because of this, the 49ers will make a comeback."  And sure enough they did.  Thankfully the Ravens held on and they deserved it much more than San Fransisco!
bluestripe18&12
SinceJan 21, 2013
-

Replay for penalties???

February 5, 2013 8:40 am

There should be a provision for contesting replay decisions, including replay of replays.  One good idea is to have attorneys for each side present their case to a judge, who makes a binding decision.  Union officials should also have input on the replay tribunal.
turds
SinceDec 17, 2011
-

Replay for penalties???

February 5, 2013 8:54 am

Nothing needs to change. Questionable calls have always occured. The difference is now every joe has a hi def tv at least 55 in. Also every idiot has a facebook,twitter, and message board account. Every questionable call is exacerbated under massive scrutiny. Questionable calls used to be announced by credible media sources and announcers.  Half of the people on here could be 11yr olds with smartphones for we know. It's really lame how everyone whines about calls. Except for the fail mary call. That was legitimate hehe
slickyricky
SinceAug 4, 2009
-

Replay for penalties???

February 5, 2013 8:59 am

At the very least, it could have been called both ways, and therefore should have been off-setting and replayed. That would have been the FAIR call to make. Both shoved the other and everyone who called it a "GOOD NO CALL" is an idiot. The mutt was falling and decided to hold so he couldn't get to the ball. Don't even waste my time and say it was an unfetchable ball, because what receivers are doing now a days in the NFL are remarkable. You CAN'T let the game end on a play so questionable as that one. GODell should be ashamed of himself!!!!!
gobigben73
SinceMay 7, 2008
-

Replay for penalties???

February 5, 2013 9:01 am

I wouldn't mind it but i doubt it would change much.  Hell they even reviewed the fail mary and screwed that up, so who is to say the would get a tic tacky call like the superbowl right? Although that was a taste of their own medicine because it was an even worse foul was in the atl game.
UCONN fan
SinceMar 15, 2009
-

Replay for penalties???

February 5, 2013 9:03 am

You CAN'T let the game end on a play so questionable as that one

Uhh moron it didn't. Sf stopped Ravens and got to return a punt. Hell if they weren't retards with their time outs they could have easily had another shot at midfeild with 45 sec left. No one to blame but themselves. They played like crap in the first half and wasted two TO's on crap.
UCONN fan
SinceMar 15, 2009
-

Replay for penalties???

February 5, 2013 9:07 am

I dont mind penalties being challenged as long as teams dont get extra challenges...  I dont like that when a play is challenged there are aspects of it that can not be challenged, and it is a shame that even a challenged play may still not get the correct call, just because the refs did not call it correctly in the first place...
yanksfan92
SinceDec 29, 2008
-

Replay for penalties???

February 5, 2013 9:08 am

Disagree 100%.  Power outage had nothing to do with comeback-ravens age + fact niners adrenaline finally kicking was reason = coincidental events.  Remember, niners came back 17 against a much younger team 2 weeks earlier, power outage or not.  Would actually argue the power outage helped that old Ravens defence, otherwise comeback would have been more dramatic and/or refs woulda had to make even more egregious calls ;-)

The better team WAS coming back because over a longer period of time (i.e. if this game had been played 10 times, niners would > 50% of the games). More talented, younger team was wearing down older team running on emotion and fumes, plain and simple.  Now the calls are another issue altogether, as was the slow start for niners.
lorenzo G.
SinceFeb 4, 2013
-

Replay for penalties???

February 5, 2013 9:12 am

Well, where was the replay on the final play of the SF/ATL game where Roddy White got mugged by Patrick Willis? You see how dumb this is? It's really hilarious hearing all this considering the Niner benefitted from a missed call when they won the NFC Title game.

But now that they feel jobbed, the whole system sucks.

Scuba061
SinceJul 29, 2009
-

Replay for penalties???

February 5, 2013 9:14 am

The better team WAS coming back because over a longer period of time

A better team doesn't go down by 17 and 22 in back to back games.
UCONN fan
SinceMar 15, 2009
-

Replay for penalties???

February 5, 2013 9:16 am

More talented, younger team was wearing down older team running on emotion and fumes, plain and simple.
Wearing them down how exactly? The Niners offense was completely ineffective and it's not like they had a bunch of sustained drives that "wore down" the Ravens. Besides, after the outage, the Ravens defense had only been on the field for very few plays in about a 90 minutes span.

Saying they were tired is not true at all. 
Scuba061
SinceJul 29, 2009
-

Replay for penalties???

February 5, 2013 9:18 am

Kind of pointless. Many pentalties today are judgment calls so reviewing them most likely wouldn't change anything anyway. It's up to that referee's discretion if he feels there is a pass inteference and how they wish to call the game. There will always be good calls and bad calls. You can't change. Part of the game. Secondly, if you reviewed all penalties the game will take freaking forever and completely remove momentum. It would almost be like watching baseball and waiting forever and day for them to actually throw a darn pitch. No thanks.
Deuce
SinceJan 2, 2007
-

Replay for penalties???

February 5, 2013 9:20 am

Disagree 100%.  Power outage had nothing to do with comeback-ravens age + fact niners adrenaline finally kicking was reason = coincidental events.
You obviously don't know a thing about momentum.  In football momentum is everything, and the outage took every last bit of the curb stomping momentum the Ravens had. 
ChubRock50
SinceOct 31, 2006
-

49ers are cheaters!!!

February 5, 2013 9:30 am

Well, where was the replay on the final play of the SF/ATL game where Roddy White got mugged by Patrick Willis? You see how dumb this is? It's really hilarious hearing all this considering the Niner benefitted from a missed call when they won the NFC Title game.


YEAH!

WHAT HE SAID!!!!!

Rod Smart
SinceFeb 4, 2011
-

Replay for penalties???

February 5, 2013 9:38 am

Momentum is great, and yes the power out helped the 49ers gain their momentum and Ravens lose it...  But so did LaMichael James fumble... before the fumble it was 7-3 on their way to scroring and possibly taking the lead.... But instead the ravens scored to make it 14-3...

That fumble was a clear face masking penalty...  so both teams gained momentum on something that should not be... so it is a wash...
yanksfan92
SinceDec 29, 2008